Market Reforms in China and India

Much of the growth stories of China and India are attributed to free-market reforms by many. To get a different perspective, here's an interesting article by Prof Bardhan. If you wonder that my Chicago influence will automatically indicate where I stand, then that would be as flippant as reading with the understanding that the author is from UC Berkeley. But jokes apart, some very important issues have been brought forth which are typically lost in popular disourse. Talking about China, he says -

"...socialist control and regulations undoubtedly inhibited initiative and enterprise in both countries, the positive legacy of reforms undertaken in the ‘70s and ‘80s cannot be denied, particularly in China’s recent pattern of state-controlled capitalist growth. China’s earlier socialist period arguably provided a good launching pad for market reform. That foundation provided wide access to education and health care; highly egalitarian land redistribution that created a rural safety net and thus eased the process of market reform, with all its wrenching disruptions and dislocations; increased female labor participation and education that enhanced women’s contribution to economic growth; and a system of regional economic decentralization"

India fares poorly in China's comparison - in equality in land owership, education, and health care. Prof Bardhan attributes this to - "... Chinese are better capitalists now because they were better socialists then!"

Interesting read overall.