Last week I found this article in the WSJ quite interesting. The NIMBY mindset that has impaired building large conventional power plants in US and in many parts of UK has crossed over to the renewables. Yes - we are talking about "green energy" and saving the environment. But not in my backyard. This is a real problem and a barrier to building anything new to address the energy needs. How do we get by this barrier?
Back in the days, when coal and nuclear were built, the big challenges were closing a set of contracts with a bunch of agencies and then arranging financing for the project. With time, the paper work and permit processes increased in volume and slowly projects were not realized because the contracts and commercials did not work out. Structural limitations throttled and abated many technically and economically viable projects. It is at this point where we find so many academic pundits and the "realists" diverge. The realists say structural barriers in contracting throws the economics out of the window while the academicians seem to be still under the belief that the economics work.
In the recent past we have entered a different era --one where NIMBY mindsets, environmentalists, and other special interest groups have been remarkably successful in stopping projects from happening. In most cases, more than the substance of the arguments - the protests are caused by narrowminded local interests providing a fertile ground for local politicians to grab a low hanging fruit to make their political careers.
This is nothing new in the way politicians behave. What is troublesome is that development gets stalled. Over and over again. Narrow selfish interests of a group of individuals overrides national interests. But what bothers me is in recent times the success in getting local interest trump national and general societal interest is quite high. This leads to -- how do we deal with this?
The NIMBY mindset is quite natural but also hard to understand. On one side we are a country of responsible people who send our kids to the war for a national interest. How is it that we can not tolerate a visual change in the middle of nowhere. Is this a mindset created out of perception or are we are ready to do some sacrifices and not something else. Either way, expecting something like green electricity will take some sacrifices just like anything else that came from someone else's blood and sweat -- whether it is the Brooklyn bridge or interstate system -- all of which we take so much for granted. We need to revive that mindset. Question is how. I will keep pondering on that.
